How to Cope With Depression Essay Example
Are you depressed, or oppressed? If you have a period of depression, you may have just tried to take things easy and improve your mood on your own. If you’ve suffered for a long time, you might seek medical help and even get prescribed antidepressants, which are supposed to help, right? The truth may shock you.
On television, you may see a commercial for Prozac, Zoloft, Celexa, and more. These are all antidepressants. The commercials often mention that taking the drug will help you out of your depression, but this may not be true in some cases. There is a ton of debate over whether antidepressants will make or break a person. You can find articles that say antidepressants are working and beneficial to a person while on the contrary, there are articles that claim they increase suicide rates in young adults and adolescents. Gary Greenberg of Harpers Magazines, “Manufacturing Depression: A Journey into the Economy of Melancholy” describes an experiment where a group of people are given a set of Celexa, an antidepressant, and placebo sugar pills. Their results were recorded after a said amount of time and Gary states, “The drugs failed to outperform the placebos.” (Source B). Now you may be thinking that the antidepressants should have outdone the placebos, right? In this case, that is not true. It was found that taking a sugar tablet with no effect at all increased the people's moods, unlike the drug that was specifically designed to have that effect.
While some sources claim that antidepressants just flat out don’t work, other sources say that the availability of newer antidepressants determine how high suicide rates are. Colby Strong of Neuropsychiatry Reviews, “Antidepressants and Suicide Risk” states that “A high number of TCA prescriptions may be a marker for those countries with more limited access to quality mental health care and inadequate treatment and detection of depression, which in turn lead to increased suicide rates. By contrast, increases in prescriptions for SSRIs and other new-generation non-SSRIs are associated with lower suicide rates.” (Source D). This shows that when newer, quality antidepressants are not available to poorer countries and older, nonfunctioning antidepressants are prescribed to those people, suicide rates increase. When those newer, quality antidepressants are available, suicide rates are decreased. What we have learned from this is that some antidepressants work, while others don’t and could even have a negative effect.
Now that we have seen standpoints saying antidepressants don’t work and antidepressants can work as long as they’re new, we introduce the idea that antidepressants work just and decrease suicide rates. Jim Rosack of psychiatric News 1’s “Suicide Rates Began to Drop with Advent of SSRIs” claims, “Suicide rates have declined steadily since the introduction of newer reuptake inhibitor antidepressants in 1988. While not proof, they said, the data strongly suggest that a direct relationship exists and that most persons who did commit suicide did so because of untreated mental illness” (Source E). This shows that if antidepressants are taken, suicide rates will drop and if you don’t take antidepressants, suicide rates will rise.
Due to the fact there is an unnecessary amount of conflicting debate on antidepressants, I believe that antidepressants are not reliable and very well may not help your mental state. While everyone is different and some people benefit from taking the pill, I do not believe that all people will have the planned effect of the treatment, resulting in a worsening in mood and to the extreme, an increased suicide rate.
- Auschwitz: The Camp of Tears
- Clinical Versus Counseling Psychology Essay Example
- Communist Manifesto Essay Example
- Essay on Colonial Women in New England
- Essay on Our Town
- Essay on Sweden
- The Double Agent of the Revolutionary War Essay Example
- My Summer Course Essay Example
- My undergraduate experience
- The Great Plague and Fire of London Essay Example